- Best-in-class bot filtering
- Built-in A/B split testing
- Server-side postback tracking
- Easiest setup of any tracker
- Affordable for any budget
Affiliate link
- AI-powered attribution
- Email & phone matching
- Long sales cycle tracking
- High-ticket optimized
- Recovers lost conversions
Affiliate link
TL;DR — Which Should You Use?
Who Each Tool Is Actually Built For
ClickMagick is built for:
- Solo affiliate marketers promoting CPA/CPS offers
- Performance advertisers running Google, Meta, TikTok ads
- eCommerce brands tracking paid traffic ROI
- Marketers who need bot filtering and click fraud protection
- Anyone who wants A/B testing built into their tracker
- Businesses spending $500–$50,000/mo on ads
Hyros is built for:
- High-ticket coaches selling $1,000–$50,000 programs
- Online course creators with long consideration cycles
- Info product businesses with complex multi-step funnels
- Businesses where email/phone matching is critical
- Marketers spending $5,000+/mo who need AI attribution
- Brands where a single recovered conversion pays for the tool
Tracking & Attribution: How They Compare
ClickMagick uses its proprietary TrueTracking technology — a combination of first-party cookies, server-side tracking, and device fingerprinting. Every click gets a unique click ID that persists across sessions. Bot filtering runs automatically on every click, removing invalid traffic before it reaches your landing page or gets counted as a conversion. The result is click-level attribution that's more accurate than what any ad platform reports.
Hyros takes a fundamentally different approach. Instead of click-level tracking, Hyros focuses on identity-based attribution — matching customers to their original ad source using their email address, phone number, and device fingerprint. When a customer provides their email at any point in your funnel, Hyros matches it to the original click source. This is especially powerful for high-ticket offers where customers might see an ad, wait weeks, and then convert through a completely different channel.
The key difference: ClickMagick is better at tracking clicks accurately. Hyros is better at tracking customers across long, complex journeys. For most affiliate marketers and performance advertisers, ClickMagick's click-level accuracy is exactly what they need. For high-ticket businesses with 30–90 day sales cycles, Hyros's identity matching can recover significant revenue.
Pricing Comparison
| Plan | ClickMagick | Hyros |
|---|---|---|
| Entry Plan | $37/mo (Starter) | ~$99/mo (custom) |
| Mid Plan | $97/mo (Standard) | ~$200–300/mo |
| Pro Plan | $197/mo (Pro) | ~$400–500/mo |
| Free Trial | 14-Day Free Trial | Demo only |
| Credit Card Required | No | Yes (for demo) |
| Pricing Transparency | Public pricing | Custom quotes |
| Events Limit | Unlimited clicks | Based on ad spend |
Ease of Use
Setup takes 30 minutes. The interface is clean and intuitive. Creating tracking links, adding pixels, and reading reports is straightforward even for beginners. Excellent documentation and video tutorials.
Setup requires onboarding support. The interface is more complex and takes 2–4 weeks to get comfortable with. Hyros provides dedicated onboarding, but the learning curve is steeper than ClickMagick.
Integrations
| Integration | ClickMagick | Hyros |
|---|---|---|
| Google Ads | ||
| Meta / Facebook Ads | ||
| TikTok Ads | ||
| Shopify | ||
| ClickFunnels | ||
| Affiliate Networks (S2S) | ||
| Zapier / Webhooks | ||
| Stripe | ||
| Kajabi / Teachable | ||
| CRM Integration | Via Zapier |
Full Feature Comparison
| Feature | ClickMagick | Hyros |
|---|---|---|
| Click Tracking | ||
| Server-Side Postback (S2S) | ||
| Bot & Fraud Filtering | Basic | |
| A/B Split Testing | ||
| Traffic Rotator | ||
| Funnel Analytics | ||
| Multi-Touch Attribution | ||
| AI Attribution | ||
| Email Matching | ||
| Phone Number Matching | ||
| Cross-Device Tracking | ||
| Real-Time Reporting | ||
| Custom Reports | ||
| Geo-Based Routing | ||
| Device-Based Routing | ||
| Free Trial | 14 Days | Demo only |
| Starting Price | $37/mo | ~$99/mo |
Final Verdict
ClickMagick wins for most marketers. It's more affordable, easier to set up, has better bot filtering, includes A/B testing, and works for virtually every type of paid traffic campaign. The 14-day free trial means you can test it with zero risk. For affiliate marketers, performance advertisers, and eCommerce brands, ClickMagick is the clear choice.
Hyros wins for high-ticket businesses with complex funnels. If you're selling $2,000+ programs, running webinar funnels, or have a sales team closing deals over the phone, Hyros's AI attribution and identity matching can recover conversions that ClickMagick would miss. The higher price is justified when a single recovered conversion is worth thousands of dollars.
The bottom line: Start with ClickMagick. It covers 90% of what most marketers need at a fraction of the price. If you scale to high-ticket offers and find you need deeper attribution, consider adding Hyros at that point.
Both links are affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ClickMagick better than Hyros?
Can I use both ClickMagick and Hyros together?
How much does Hyros cost compared to ClickMagick?
Does Hyros have a free trial?
Which tool is better for Facebook ads?
Found this useful? Share it